The Rhetoric of Academic Writing
The Graduate WritingCenterTo make an appointment with a consultant:https://secure.gradsch.psu.edu/wccal/studentview.cfmNicoletteHylanMatthew Price
“The artful blend of fact and opinion”Audience—what do they expect, know, already hold as an opinion?Ethos—what is your relationship to your audience and to your subject? What is your authority?Context—in what venue will your work be published or presented?Exigence—what is your reason for writing?
Research articles contribute new knowledge to a particular fieldIntroduction concerns:Establish a question to answer, problem to solveAnswer the “so what?” questionExplain why filling the gap in previous research mattersState your thesis
Organize your dolls!Metadiscourse:Authorial contract (promise)“In this paper, I aim (contend/argue)…”Textual features (signposts)“In order to understand A, one must first recognize B.”“Contrary to point A, I would like to suggest point B.Most importantly to my argument, A suggests…”
Coherence denotes a sense of connection between individual sentences and paragraphs. It is achieved through the following strategies:Strong topic sentencesTransition words and phrasesStyle and readability
Strong Topic Sentences
A topic sentence accomplishes the following tasks:1.Expresses a claim (not a fact) that supports the larger thesis2. Indicates the content of the paragraph2.Creates a transition from the previous paragraph
Example: “Although these critics have diagnosed Hamlet with indecision, his fatal flaw in fact lies in his hastiness.”
Style and Readability
Active versus passive voice“Moby Dick is pursued by the monomaniacal Captain Ahab.”“Captain Ahab’s monomania drives him to pursue Moby Dick.”Weak linking verbs“Horatio Alger is an American writer who produced hundreds of popular novels for young boys.”“The American writer Horatio Alger produced hundreds of popular novels for young boys.”When to use “I”Open and close paragraphs with YOUR words, not quotes.Effective use of punctuationIn the final scene, Hamlet reveals the truth: he has poisoned Claudius and himself.Hamlet ‘s famous soliloquy has elicited much critical commentary; it remains, however, difficult to interpret.The old king—Hamlet’s father—continues to haunt Hamlet throughout the play.
Addition (furthermore, more importantly, additionally, moreover, similarly)Exemplification (One example of this ______, for instance)Opposition (on the other hand, conversely, in contrast)Similarity (Likewise, similarly, in the same way)Cause and effect (because of this ___, as a result, consequently, therefore, for that reason)Time order (subsequently, afterward, prior to this ___, consequently, previously)Avoid beginning with For, And, Nor, But, Or, Yet, So.See also: https://www.msu.edu/~jdowell/135/transw.html
Scientific Research Proposals
A scientific research proposal serves the following functions:Outlines the goals, methods , disciplinary context , and significance of your proposed studyConvinces your scientific audience that the topic you propose to investigate is worth exploringPersuades your audience that you will conduct your study in a sensible wayDemonstrates your familiarity with relevant research in the field and establishes that you are qualified to carry out the proposed research
A literature review charts the existing research on your topic(s) in a way that demonstrates the significance of your work to the broader field. It accomplishes the following tasks:Provides background information on your topicEstablishes the importance of your topic to the fieldCarves out a space for your work by highlighting weaknesses or gaps in the researchIdentifies trends or major ideas in the research that you are building on, or that are necessary to understand your argumentSituates your work in relation to other prominent perspectives and methodologies
A book review briefly summarizes and evaluates a published scholarly work.
Summarizing :Outline central argument, evidence, and methodologiesHighlight important sections of the bookConnect to major debates in the field, or in the author’s other work
Evaluating :Assess quality of research, argument, methodology, prose style, and use of evidenceMeasure the significance of the study to the broader fieldClarify implicit arguments or implications that may not be immediately clear
Abstracts (for Conferences)
Abstract for conferences should succinctly accomplish the following tasks:Establish your object of study and main argumentBriefly detail your methodology and use of evidenceContextualize your study within the broader fieldEstablish your work’s importance to that field
Reaction papers require you to analyze, synthesize, and/or critically respond to a reading assignment. You might approach this assignment in one of the following ways:Identify what was most valuable or interesting about the reading.Offer a critical evaluation of the central argument or methodologyTrace an idea that emerges in the text, and elaborate the significance of that idea.Explain how this reading relates to other works you’ve read in the course
Identify rhetorical and stylistic weaknesses in the following paragraph, and suggest methods for revision:
“Foam applications” is the phrase used to describe the process that applies additives to a moving paper web as foam. This process has many advantages over conventional liquid applications. Two problems have hindered the progress of this new technology. The process must be established in the paper industry. The speed limits encountered in the current application technology must be increased in order to expand the number of paper machines that can potentially use foam. The development work run at the Placerville plant is attacking both of these problem areas, and this report summarizes the achievements that have been accomplished there during the year.